How to Negotiate a Better Settlement Agreement: Tips for Employees

settlement agreement - woman at desk

What Is a Settlement Agreement?

A settlement agreement is a legal contract where you and your employer agree to end your employment on specific terms. In exchange for a payment (often called a termination payment), you agree not to pursue claims like unfair dismissal or discrimination in an employment tribunal. These agreements are voluntary, and you must get independent legal advice for them to be valid – your employer typically covers this cost.

We can help you 

In 2025, settlement agreements are increasingly common due to economic shifts, hybrid working disputes, and potential laws like the Employment Rights Bill affecting confidentiality clauses.

Why Negotiate Your Settlement Agreement?

Negotiating isn’t just about getting more money – it’s about securing terms that protect your future. A well-negotiated agreement can mean better financial support, improved job prospects, or fewer restrictions on your next steps. With UK employment law evolving in 2025, particularly around non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), knowing your rights is key to avoiding unfair terms.

Top Negotiation Tips for Employees in 2025

Here’s a straightforward guide to negotiating a better settlement agreement:

1. Understand Your Entitlements

Before negotiating, know what you’re already owed. This includes:

  • Statutory Redundancy Pay: If redundancy is the reason, check your eligibility (e.g., two years’ service) and calculate your entitlement using gov.uk tools.
  • Notice Pay: Ensure you’re getting paid for your notice period or time to work it.
  • Accrued Benefits: Confirm holiday pay, bonuses, or commission owed.
  • Tax-Free Payments: Up to £30,000 of a termination payment is usually tax-free, but double-check with a tax adviser.
 

Knowing your baseline gives you a strong starting point. For example, if the offer doesn’t cover statutory redundancy, push for it.

2. Get Expert Legal Advice Early

You’re required to get independent legal advice, and your employer typically pays for it (often £350–£1,000). Use this to your advantage:

  • Choose a solicitor specialising in employment law, not just the one your employer suggests.
  • Ask them to review the agreement for hidden clauses or unfair terms, like overly restrictive covenants.
  • Discuss what’s negotiable – they’ll know what’s reasonable based on UK law and local trends (e.g., Manchester’s tech sector or Birmingham’s manufacturing).

3. Negotiate the Financial Package

Don’t accept the first offer – it’s often a starting point. Try these:

  • Ask for More Money: If the ex-gratia payment feels low, benchmark it against industry norms or your length of service. For example, one month’s salary per year served is a common ask.
  • Include Bonuses or Benefits: If you’re offered a deal near bonus season (common in March 2025), negotiate to include performance bonuses or pro-rated amounts.
  • Request Outplacement Support: Ask for career coaching or job search help, especially if you’re in a competitive market like London.

4. Check Restrictive Covenants

These clauses on your settlement agreement can limit your next job by stopping you from working for competitors or contacting clients. In 2025, courts are stricter about enforcing unreasonable covenants:

  • Negotiate to narrow their scope (e.g., reduce a 12-month restriction to 6 months).
  • Ensure they’re specific to your role and location – a blanket UK-wide ban might not hold up.
  • If you’re in cities like Leeds or Bristol, where industries are tight-knit, this is especially important.

5. Secure a Good Reference

The Employment Rights Bill in 2025 may void clauses that prevent you from reporting workplace harassment or discrimination. Check that:

  • An agreed reference in writing, included in the agreement.
  • Neutral language if a glowing one isn’t possible – avoid anything vague or negative.
  • Confirmation that verbal references match the written one.

6. Understand NDA and Confidentiality Changes

The Employment Rights Bill in 2025 may void clauses that prevent you from reporting workplace harassment or discrimination. Check that:

  • An agreed reference in writing, included in the agreement.
  • Neutral language if a glowing one isn’t possible – avoid anything vague or negative.
  • Confirmation that verbal references match the written one.

7. Take Your Time

ACAS recommends at least 10 days to consider the offer. Don’t feel pressured:

  • If your employer rushes you, note it – but you may want to get it resolved quickly as well.
  • Use this time to consult your solicitor and weigh your options.
  • Document all communications for your records.

8. Consider Non-Financial Benefits

Think beyond the payout:

  • Extended Benefits: Ask for continued health insurance or gym memberships for a few months.
  • Training Support: Request funding for courses to boost your employability.
  • Flexible Terms: If you’re leaving due to hybrid working disputes, negotiate a phased exit to ease the transition.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid with Settlement Agreements

  • Overlooking Tax Implications: Payments over £30,000 may be taxable – clarify with an adviser.
  • Ignoring Restrictive Covenants: These can limit your career for months or years.
  • Signing Too Quickly: Pressure to sign fast can lead to missed opportunities.
  • Not Checking Exclusions: Ensure the agreement doesn’t waive rights you want to keep, like pension claims.

Final Thoughts

Negotiating a settlement agreement in 2025 is about knowing your rights, getting expert advice, and pushing for terms that reflect your value. Whether you’re in Cheshire, Merseyside, or anywhere in the UK, don’t settle for less than you deserve.